How Indian media can become better

27 Jan

The New York Times quotes Thomas Jefferson, one of the founding fathers of American democracy as having said that “he would rather have newspapers without government than government without newspapers.”

If such is the exalted status which a founder of the world’s oldest democracy gave to the media, it is perhaps important for the media in India to take itself more seriously, and get over its highly individualistic attempts at capturing the Indian market.  I propose a few solutions geared to making the media more credible, and of greater utility:

1.  Start with the entire industry agreeing to regulate itself, rather than force the government to clamp down on it.

2. Such regulation should cover:

a.  Minimum standards of content,

b. Transparency regarding the methods by which it covers news and communicates it,

c. Investment in R&D – train young journalists thoroughly so that standards and ethics are in-built rather than enforced, and lastly,

d. A system of sanctions or penalties to ensure those violating these regulations do not get away with it.  This is important as no system of rules can work without ensuring that there is a cost attached to not abiding by them.

It is imperative that the media agrees to govern itself.  Everyone propounds that in the end, free-markets ensure the best results in terms of the final product, and motivating those entrepreneurs (read journalists) to get the best news possible.  However, free markets work best when there is: a. complete transparency, and b.  when there is a low-cost attached in operating in the market (read costs of infrastructure, broadcasting, production etc.).

Complete transparency, and a collective decision to abide by certain minimum standards in many cases, automatically reduces costs of operating in the market.  Therefore, it is essential that there should be self-imposed regulations by which the entire industry agrees to operate.

There are numerous big, noteworthy associations of journalists and newspapers who can take the initiative to frame such regulations.  It is increasingly important that some internal regulatory framework be created at the earliest.

A final analogy for the incentive to frame such regulations:  Corporate Social Responsibility.  One of the reasons companies indulge in CSR is that it increases their credibility within society, and creates a positive image regarding them and their products.  So, they agree to perform certain activities which do not benefit them directly, but end up creating a positive vibe regarding them in society, which in the long run may benefit them.

The Indian media has to take time out from its daily rush to churn news out, and think in terms of gaining greater credibility in the eyes of consumers.  This can only be done by agreeing to set common minimum standards, and letting their audience know that they are going to stick by them.

Advertisements

5 Responses to “How Indian media can become better”

  1. Instinct January 30, 2011 at 4:53 am #

    The media is bent upon sensationalizing events. Like most business ventures, it is willing to do anything to generate revenue. Club those intentions with implicit political affiliations, and it may never be able to function as a transparent entity.

    The enforcement of standards will depend on the magnitude of the penalties rather the training given to its journalists. Training does not necessarily translate into ethical behavior in most cases, but fear of the penalties does.

    Like

  2. aburman January 30, 2011 at 2:52 pm #

    while i agree that training does not necessarily lead to enforcement of standards, it at least gives necessary skills to journalists to help them work better, by putting out more informed, nuanced news stories. Enforcement of standards is an issue where journalists deviate from established norms/ ethics. That does not solve the problem of capacity-building.

    Like

    • Instinct January 30, 2011 at 3:06 pm #

      Question.. Would you rather read well written articles by trained professionals who massage the truth or crudely written ones which stick to the ugly picture that is the truth?

      PS: I also need you to clarify what you mean by capacity-building

      Like

  3. aburman January 30, 2011 at 3:17 pm #

    I would read neither. I would address both issues – impose strict sanctions for those who “massage the truth” to put it mildly, and ensure those who are keen to represent the truth can do so with a sense of balance, and in-depth analysis of issues involved.

    By capacity-building, I mean that media organisations have to train young journalists in specific areas that they wish to concentrate on. Training would also involve imparting knowledge of journalistic research methods (I am sure there are some), as well as knowledge of the ethical grey areas.

    Like

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Tweets that mention How Indian media can become better « India as an evolving polity -- Topsy.com - January 29, 2011

    […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Anirudh Burman, Anirudh Burman. Anirudh Burman said: How Indian media can become better: http://wp.me/pJSZp-4Z […]

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Bar and Bench

Observations on legal and political developments in India

Firstpost

Observations on legal and political developments in India

Mainstream Weekly

Observations on legal and political developments in India

Scholars without Borders

Observations on legal and political developments in India

Legal Blog

Observations on legal and political developments in India

LAW RESOURCE INDIA

LEGAL RESOURCE CENTRE / COURT JUDGMENTS / LEGAL ARCHIVES

India Together

Observations on legal and political developments in India

Concurring Opinions

Observations on legal and political developments in India

Bar & Bench

Observations on legal and political developments in India

Law and Other Things

Observations on legal and political developments in India

sans serif

the news. the views. the juice.

%d bloggers like this: